more from this thinker     |     more from this text

Single Idea 17443

[filed under theme 7. Existence / C. Structure of Existence / 4. Ontological Dependence ]

Full Idea

Frege sometimes speaks of 'the dependence of truths upon one another' (1884:§2), but I find such ideas obscure, and suspect I'm not the only one who does.

Gist of Idea

Many of us find Frege's claim that truths depend on one another an obscure idea

Source

comment on Gottlob Frege (Grundlagen der Arithmetik (Foundations) [1884], §02) by Richard G. Heck - Cardinality, Counting and Equinumerosity 1

Book Ref

-: 'Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic' [-], p.190

A Reaction

He refers to Burge 'struggling mightily' with this aspect of Frege's thought. I intend to defend Frege. See his 1914 lectures. I thought this dependence was basic to the whole modern project of doing metaphysics through logic?

Related Idea

Idea 17445 Parallelism is intuitive, so it is more fundamental than sameness of direction [Frege, by Heck]

The 17 ideas with the same theme [things that rely on other things for their existence]:

1699 A thing is prior to another if it implies its existence [Aristotle]
18366 Of interdependent things, the prior one causes the other's existence [Aristotle]
24057 What is prior is always potentially present in what is next in order [Aristotle]
11154 Prior things can exist without posterior things, but not vice versa [Aristotle]
17443 Many of us find Frege's claim that truths depend on one another an obscure idea [Heck on Frege]
17445 Parallelism is intuitive, so it is more fundamental than sameness of direction [Frege, by Heck]
17656 Being primitive or prior always depends on a constructional system [Goodman]
11919 Ontological dependence rests on essential connection, not necessary connection [Molnar]
11151 An object is dependent if its essence prevents it from existing without some other object [Fine,K]
14251 A natural modal account of dependence says x depends on y if y must exist when x does [Fine,K]
14257 An object depends on another if the second cannot be eliminated from the first's definition [Fine,K]
14254 Dependency is the real counterpart of one term defining another [Fine,K]
14261 There is 'weak' dependence in one definition, and 'strong' dependence in all the definitions [Fine,K]
12879 Independent objects can exist apart, and maybe even entirely alone [Simons]
14091 There may be a one-way direction of dependence among sets, and among natural numbers [Linnebo]
17327 Non-causal dependence is at present only dimly understood [Liggins]
17720 There's essential, modal, explanatory, conceptual, metaphysical and constitutive dependence [Jenkins, by PG]