more on this theme
|
more from this thinker
Single Idea 15032
[filed under theme 10. Modality / C. Sources of Modality / 3. Necessity by Convention
]
Full Idea
Sidelle defends conventionalism against a posteriori necessities by 'factoring' a necessary a posteriori truth into an analytic component and a nonmodal component. The modal force then comes from the analytic part, and the a posteriority from the other.
Gist of Idea
Necessary a posteriori is conventional for necessity and nonmodal for a posteriority
Source
report of Alan Sidelle (Necessity, Essence and Individuation [1989]) by Theodore Sider - Writing the Book of the World 12.8
Book Ref
Sider,Theodore: 'Writing the Book of the World' [OUP 2011], p.282
A Reaction
[I note that Sidelle refers, it seems, to the nonmodal component as a 'deep explanatory feature', which is exactly what I take an essence to be].
The
22 ideas
from 'Necessity, Essence and Individuation'
15032
|
Necessary a posteriori is conventional for necessity and nonmodal for a posteriority
[Sidelle, by Sider]
|
15167
|
Empiricism explores necessities and concept-limits by imagining negations of truths
[Sidelle]
|
15165
|
A priori knowledge is entirely of analytic truths
[Sidelle]
|
15168
|
That water is essentially H2O in some way concerns how we use 'water'
[Sidelle]
|
15166
|
Causal reference seems to get directly at the object, thus leaving its nature open
[Sidelle]
|
15169
|
Metaphysics is clarifying how we speak and think (and possibly improving it)
[Sidelle]
|
15164
|
We seem to base necessities on thought experiments and imagination
[Sidelle]
|
15172
|
Clearly, essential predications express necessary properties
[Sidelle]
|
15173
|
That the essence of water is its microstructure is a convention, not a discovery
[Sidelle]
|
15171
|
The necessary a posteriori is statements either of identity or of essence
[Sidelle]
|
15176
|
The individuals and kinds involved in modality are also a matter of convention
[Sidelle]
|
15174
|
A thing doesn't need transworld identity prior to rigid reference - that could be a convention of the reference
[Sidelle]
|
15175
|
Evaluation of de dicto modalities does not depend on the identity of its objects
[Sidelle]
|
15180
|
There doesn't seem to be anything in the actual world that can determine modal facts
[Sidelle]
|
15181
|
Being a deepest explanatory feature is an actual, not a modal property
[Sidelle]
|
15177
|
Contradictoriness limits what is possible and what is imaginable
[Sidelle]
|
15179
|
To know empirical necessities, we need empirical facts, plus conventions about which are necessary
[Sidelle]
|
15178
|
Can anything in science reveal the necessity of what it discovers?
[Sidelle]
|
15182
|
Because some entities overlap, reference must have analytic individuation principles
[Sidelle]
|
15184
|
Causal reference presupposes essentialism if it refers to modally extended entities
[Sidelle]
|
15185
|
We aren't clear about 'same stuff as this', so a principle of individuation is needed to identify it
[Sidelle]
|
15183
|
'Dthat' operates to make a singular term into a rigid term
[Sidelle]
|